Search Results
Working Paper
The Economics of Debt Collection: Enforcement of Consumer Credit Contracts
Hunt, Robert M.; Fedaseyeu, Viktar
(2018-01-29)
Creditors often outsource the task of obtaining repayment from defaulting borrowers to third-party debt collectors. We argue that by hiring third-party debt collectors, creditors can avoid competing in terms of their debt collection practices. This explanation fits several empirical facts about third-party debt collection and is consistent with the evidence that third-party debt collectors use harsher debt collection practices than original creditors. Our model shows that the impact of third-party debt collectors on consumer welfare depends on the riskiness of the pool of borrowers and ...
Working Papers
, Paper 18-4
Discussion Paper
Balances Are on the Rise—So Who Is Taking on More Credit Card Debt?
Haughwout, Andrew F.; Lee, Donghoon; Mangrum, Daniel; Scally, Joelle; Van der Klaauw, Wilbert
(2022-11-15)
Total household debt balances continued their upward climb in the third quarter of 2022 with an increase of $351 billion, the largest nominal quarterly increase since 2007. This rise was driven by a $282 billion increase in mortgage balances, according to the latest Quarterly Report on Household Debt & Credit from the New York Fed’s Center for Microeconomic Data. Mortgages, historically the largest form of household debt, now comprise 71 percent of outstanding household debt balances, up from 69 percent in the fourth quarter of 2019. An increase in credit card balances was also a boost to ...
Liberty Street Economics
, Paper 20221115b
Report
Do Consumers Rely More Heavily on Credit Cards While Unemployed?
Cole, Allison
(2016-12-20)
Leading up to the Great Recession, households increased their credit card debt by over 16 percent ($121 billion) during the five-year period from 2004 to 2009. The unemployment rate simultaneously began to rise in 2008, increasing from 5.0 percent in January 2008 to a high of 10.0 percent in October of 2009. During the recovery, from 2009 to 2014, credit card debt fell by more than 25 percent, as the unemployment rate returned to near prerecession levels. These coincident developments have led to speculation that consumers facing unemployment or job uncertainty may have increased their ...
Consumer Payments Research Data Reports
, Paper 2016-06
Working Paper
The Conundrum of Zero APR: An Analytical Framework
Drozd, Lukasz A.; Kowalik, Michal
(2023-03-13)
We document the prevalence of promotional pricing of credit card debt in the U.S. and develop an analytic framework to study how interest rates on multiperiod credit line contracts should be set when debt is unsecured and defaultable. We show that according to the basic theory of unsecured credit — suitably extended to allow for promotions — interest rates should price in the expected default risk on a period-by-period basis. The inspection of our model’s mechanism implies that time-consistent consumption behavior is crucial for this result; accordingly, modeling time-inconsistent ...
Working Papers
, Paper 23-06
Discussion Paper
What Happens during Mortgage Forbearance?
Haughwout, Andrew F.; Lee, Donghoon; Scally, Joelle; Van der Klaauw, Wilbert
(2021-05-19)
As we discussed in our previous post, millions of mortgage borrowers have entered forbearance since the beginning of the pandemic, and more than 2 million remain in a program as of March 2021. In this post, we use our Consumer Credit Panel (CCP) data to examine borrower behavior while in forbearance. The credit bureau data are ideal for this purpose because they allow us to follow borrowers over time, and to connect developments on the mortgage with those on other credit products. We find that forbearance results in reduced mortgage delinquencies and is associated with increased paydown of ...
Liberty Street Economics
, Paper 20210519b
Report
The 2017 Diary of Consumer Payment Choice
Greene, Claire; Stavins, Joanna
(2020-04-01)
This paper describes key results from the 2017 Diary of Consumer Payment Choice (DCPC), the fourth in a series of diary surveys that measure payment behavior through the daily recording of U.S. consumers' spending. The DCPC is the only diary survey of U.S. consumer payments available free to the public. In October 2017, consumers paid mostly with cash (30.3 percent of payments), debit cards (26.2 percent), and credit cards (21.0 percent). These instruments accounted for three-quarters of the number of payments, but only about 40 percent of the total value of payments, because they tend to be ...
Consumer Payments Research Data Reports
, Paper 2018-5
Working Paper
Managing Risk in Cards Portfolios: Risk Appetite and Limits
Eder, Tiffany; Labonne, Claire; O'Loughlin, Caitlin; Sharma, Krish
(2024-02-15)
We describe an important risk management tool at financial institutions, risk appetite frameworks. We observe those frameworks for credit cards portfolios at four large banks and analyze when and why banks adjust them. The risk appetite frameworks for these banks monitor 40 to 150 metrics. We focus on metrics related to outstanding balances of which we identified 79. Overall, we find that these frameworks are sticky. Most adjustments occur during scheduled annual reviews and are relatively limited. Limit breaches are rare. Thresholds are often changed the month after a breach or after the ...
Supervisory Research and Analysis Working Papers
, Paper 24-01
Discussion Paper
Why Are Credit Card Rates So High?
Drechsler, Itamar; Jung, Hyeyoon; Peng, Weiyu; Supera, Dominik; Zhou, Guanyu
(2025-03-31)
Credit cards play a crucial role in U.S. consumer finance, with 74 percent of adults having at least one. They serve as the main method of payment for most individuals, accounting for 70 percent of retail spending. They are also the primary source of unsecured borrowing, with 60 percent of accounts carrying a balance from one month to the next. Surprisingly, credit card interest rates are very high, averaging 23 percent annually in 2023. Indeed, their rates are far higher than the rates on any other major type of loan or bond. Why are credit card rates so high? In our recent research paper, ...
Liberty Street Economics
, Paper 20250331
Working Paper
Distributional Effects of Payment Card Pricing and Merchant Cost Pass-through in the United States and Canada
Hayashi, Fumiko; Felt, Marie-Hélène; Welte, Angelika; Stavins, Joanna
(2020-12-01)
Using data from the United States and Canada, we quantify consumers’ net pecuniary cost of using cash, credit cards, and debit cards for purchases across income cohorts. The net cost includes fees paid to financial institutions, rewards received from credit or debit card issuers, and the merchant cost of accepting payments that is passed on to consumers as higher retail prices. Even though credit cards are more expensive for merchants to accept compared with other payment methods, merchants typically do not differentiate prices at checkout, but instead pass through their costs to all ...
Working Papers
, Paper 20-13
Discussion Paper
Consumer Payment Preferences and the Impact of Technology and Regulation: Insights from the Visa Payment Panel Study
Akana, Tom
(2019-07-02)
The Consumer Finance Institute hosted a workshop in August 2018 featuring Michael Marx, senior director at Visa, Inc., to discuss recent data from the Visa Payment Panel, highlighting the evolution of consumer payment preferences since the Great Recession and the passage of the Credit Card Accountability Responsibility and Disclosure (CARD) Act of 2009. A number of intriguing trends were discussed. Debit card adoption and growth have shown signs of slowing, even as regulatory changes have increased its prevalence recently among younger consumers. Credit card usage continues to grow and has ...
Consumer Finance Institute discussion papers
, Paper 19-1
FILTER BY year
FILTER BY Bank
Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia 20 items
Federal Reserve Bank of New York 17 items
Federal Reserve Bank of Boston 15 items
Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta 14 items
Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago 3 items
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis 3 items
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (U.S.) 2 items
Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas 2 items
Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City 1 items
show more (4)
show less
FILTER BY Series
Working Papers 16 items
Consumer Payments Research Data Reports 14 items
Liberty Street Economics 14 items
Consumer Finance Institute discussion papers 8 items
Research Data Report 7 items
Staff Reports 3 items
Chicago Fed Letter 2 items
Current Policy Perspectives 2 items
Finance and Economics Discussion Series 2 items
Page One Economics Newsletter 2 items
Dallas Fed Communities 1 items
Economic Insights 1 items
New England Public Policy Center Regional Brief 1 items
On the Economy 1 items
Payments System Research Briefing 1 items
Profitwise 1 items
Supervisory Research and Analysis Working Papers 1 items
show more (12)
show less
FILTER BY Content Type
Report 26 items
Discussion Paper 22 items
Working Paper 19 items
Newsletter 4 items
Briefing 2 items
Journal Article 2 items
show more (1)
show less
FILTER BY Author
Stavins, Joanna 22 items
Greene, Claire 19 items
Van der Klaauw, Wilbert 8 items
Scally, Joelle 7 items
Schuh, Scott 7 items
Chakrabarti, Rajashri 6 items
Foster, Kevin 6 items
Haughwout, Andrew F. 6 items
Lee, Donghoon 6 items
Akana, Tom 3 items
Avtar, Ruchi 3 items
Fulford, Scott L. 3 items
Hunt, Robert M. 3 items
Pinkovskiy, Maxim L. 3 items
Blascak, Nathan 2 items
Chatterji-Len, Kasey 2 items
Cole, Allison 2 items
Drechsler, Itamar 2 items
Drozd, Lukasz A. 2 items
Fedaseyeu, Viktar 2 items
Jagtiani, Julapa 2 items
Jung, Hyeyoon 2 items
Mangrum, Daniel 2 items
Peng, Weiyu 2 items
Supera, Dominik 2 items
Topa, Giorgio 2 items
Tranfaglia, Anna 2 items
Zhou, Guanyu 2 items
Agarwal, Sumit 1 items
An, Xudong 1 items
Armantier, Olivier 1 items
Bennett, Jeannette N. 1 items
Bradford, Terri 1 items
Brown, Meta 1 items
Calem, Paul S. 1 items
Campbell, Graham 1 items
Chiang, Yu-Ting 1 items
Cooper, Daniel H. 1 items
Cordell, Lawrence R. 1 items
DiMaggio, Marco 1 items
Dolson, Erik 1 items
Dou, Yiwei 1 items
Dueholm, Mick 1 items
Eder, Tiffany 1 items
Felt, Marie-Hélène 1 items
Ge, Shan 1 items
George, Taz 1 items
Gresenz, Carole Roan 1 items
Haddix, Maddie 1 items
Han, Song 1 items
Hartley, Daniel 1 items
Hayashi, Fumiko 1 items
Heise, Sebastian 1 items
Hertzberg, Andrew 1 items
Ionescu, Felicia 1 items
Ionescu, Marius 1 items
Johnson, Stephanie 1 items
Ke, Wei 1 items
Kermani, Amir 1 items
Keys, Benjamin J. 1 items
Kowalik, Michal 1 items
Labonne, Claire 1 items
Lanning, Jonathan 1 items
Li, Geng 1 items
Maingi, Ramain Quinn 1 items
Mazumder, Bhashkar 1 items
Melcangi, Davide 1 items
Mitchell, Jean M 1 items
Morgan, Donald P. 1 items
Newberger, Robin G. 1 items
Nober, William 1 items
O'Dell, Mark 1 items
O'Loughlin, Caitlin 1 items
Peate, Mary Clare 1 items
Phelan, Felicity 1 items
Psathas, Peter 1 items
Rajan, Aastha 1 items
Ramasamy, Chellappan 1 items
Ramcharan, Rodney 1 items
Rodriguez, Belicia 1 items
Roman, Raluca 1 items
Ronen, Joshua 1 items
Rose, Jonathan D. 1 items
Ryder Perlmeter, Emily 1 items
Santucci, Larry 1 items
Santucci, Lawrence 1 items
Serfes, Konstantinos 1 items
Serrano-Padial, Ricardo 1 items
Severino, Felipe 1 items
Sharma, Krish 1 items
Smith, Kyle 1 items
Turner, R. Scott 1 items
Tzur-Ilan, Nitzan 1 items
Wang, Jenna 1 items
Welte, Angelika 1 items
Wilshusen, Stephanie M. 1 items
Yu, Edison 1 items
Zhang, Yin 1 items
show more (93)
show less
FILTER BY Jel Classification
D14 41 items
E42 22 items
D12 21 items
G21 14 items
G51 11 items
G28 8 items
D91 5 items
D1 4 items
D18 4 items
E21 4 items
G53 3 items
Q12 3 items
D15 2 items
G12 2 items
G20 2 items
G23 2 items
G41 2 items
H81 2 items
J16 2 items
J6 2 items
L24 2 items
R10 2 items
C23 1 items
D10 1 items
D31 1 items
D80 1 items
E02 1 items
E2 1 items
E27 1 items
E52 1 items
G01 1 items
G18 1 items
G22 1 items
G32 1 items
G33 1 items
G38 1 items
G5 1 items
G50 1 items
G52 1 items
I1 1 items
I22 1 items
L13 1 items
L21 1 items
L40 1 items
L81 1 items
O35 1 items
Q54 1 items
R21 1 items
R3 1 items
Z1 1 items
show more (45)
show less
FILTER BY Keywords
checking accounts 19 items
debit cards 19 items
cash 18 items
checks 18 items
payment preferences 18 items
prepaid cards 18 items
electronic payments 15 items
unbanked 11 items
Survey of Consumer Payment Choice 9 items
mortgage 6 items
Diary of Consumer Payment Choice 5 items
household finances 5 items
student loans 5 items
CARD Act 4 items
COVID-19 4 items
consumer credit 4 items
consumer behavior 3 items
credit 3 items
debt 3 items
delinquency 3 items
electronic payments 3 items
mortgages 3 items
unemployment 3 items
CCP 2 items
CUNY 2 items
Consumer credit 2 items
Consumer payment choice 2 items
account graduation 2 items
asset pricing 2 items
auto 2 items
auto loans 2 items
banking 2 items
consumer credit markets 2 items
consumer credit panel 2 items
consumer spending 2 items
contract enforcement 2 items
credit card debt 2 items
credit limits 2 items
credit scores 2 items
debit card 2 items
debt collection 2 items
decomposition 2 items
gender 2 items
household debt 2 items
household finance 2 items
inequality 2 items
interchange fees 2 items
regulation of credit markets 2 items
secured credit cards 2 items
student debt 2 items
Bankruptcy reform 1 items
Ch. 13 1 items
Ch. 7 1 items
Consumer Credit Panel (CCP) 1 items
Consumer debt 1 items
Consumer payments 1 items
Credit supply 1 items
Debt collection 1 items
Debt repayment 1 items
Default 1 items
FDCPA 1 items
Fair Debt Collections Practices Act 1 items
Great Recession 1 items
HELOC 1 items
New England 1 items
New York (City) 1 items
P2P 1 items
P2P lending 1 items
Target 1 items
ability to pay 1 items
alternative credit 1 items
auto lenders 1 items
auto loan 1 items
bank reputation 1 items
bank stress tests 1 items
banking supervision 1 items
bankruptcy 1 items
buffer stock 1 items
census tract 1 items
climate change 1 items
consumer preferences 1 items
consumer credit access 1 items
consumer debts 1 items
consumer finance 1 items
consumer preferences 1 items
consumption 1 items
contactless 1 items
cost of credit 1 items
costly state verification 1 items
credit access 1 items
credit card utilization 1 items
credit offers 1 items
credit performance 1 items
credit supply 1 items
credit usage 1 items
data breach 1 items
default risk 1 items
delinquency and default 1 items
delinquency rates 1 items
demographics 1 items
fintech 1 items
gamification 1 items
household saving and borrowing 1 items
households 1 items
income 1 items
informal bankruptcy 1 items
information asymmetry 1 items
information technology 1 items
insurance 1 items
lending practices 1 items
life cycle 1 items
longer maturities 1 items
longer-term borrowings 1 items
mail solicitation 1 items
memory disorders 1 items
merchant competition 1 items
mobile payments 1 items
moral hazard 1 items
mortgage forbearance 1 items
mortgage lending 1 items
observable characteristics 1 items
online community 1 items
online lending 1 items
origination vintages 1 items
pandemic 1 items
panel 1 items
participation inequality 1 items
pass-through entities 1 items
payment card security 1 items
payment cards 1 items
payment deferral 1 items
payment pause 1 items
personal bankruptcy 1 items
personal finance 1 items
personal lending 1 items
point-of-sale payments 1 items
precaution 1 items
prepayment 1 items
promotional introductory offers 1 items
race 1 items
recession 1 items
regressive effects 1 items
regulation 1 items
reopening 1 items
revolving credit 1 items
rewards 1 items
risk appetite framework 1 items
risk limits 1 items
risk management 1 items
saving 1 items
savings accounts 1 items
secured 1 items
subprime mortgages 1 items
tap-and-pay 1 items
two sided networks 1 items
unsecured credit 1 items
unsecured debt 1 items
zero APR 1 items
show more (154)
show less