Household Credit and Local Economic Uncertainty

DiMaggio, Marco; Kermani, Amir; Ramcharan, Rodney; Yu, Edison

Working Paper

Household Credit and Local Economic Uncertainty

Abstract: This paper investigates the impact of uncertainty on consumer credit outcomes. We develop a local measure of economic uncertainty capturing county-level labor market shocks. We then exploit microeconomic data on mortgages and credit-card balances together with the crosssectional variation provided by our uncertainty measure to show strong borrower-specific heterogeneity in response to changes in uncertainty. Among high risk borrowers or areas with more high risk borrowers, increased uncertainty is associated with housing market illiquidity and a reduction in leverage. For low risk borrowers, these effects are absent and the cost of mortgage credit declines, suggesting that lenders reallocate credit towards safer borrowers when uncertainty spikes. A similar pattern is observed in the unsecured credit market. Taken together, local uncertainty might independently affect aggregate economic activity through consumer credit markets and could engender greater inequality in consumption and housing wealth accumulation across households.

Keywords: consumer credit; mortgages; credit cards; lending practices; ;

JEL Classification: D14; D80; E52; G21;