Working Paper
The Wisdom of the Crowd? Firm Expectations, Disagreement, and Real GDP Forecast Accuracy
Abstract: We compare probabilistic real GDP growth forecasts from the CFO Survey with those from the Survey of Professional Forecasters (SPF). Both surveys elicit full probability distributions, so in addition to forecast accuracy, we can measure subjective uncertainty within forecasters and disagreement across them. CFO forecasts are substantially more dispersed than SPF forecasts: cross-sectional disagreement among CFOs is roughly three times as large as among professional forecasters. At the individual level, CFO respondents exhibit larger absolute errors and higher forecast-error variance. Yet this greater individual-level noise does not translate into worse consensus forecasts. Aggregated CFO forecasts track SPF forecasts closely and achieve statistically similar consensus accuracy. Decompositions of ex-ante forecast variance and ex-post mean squared error show that CFO disagreement reflects heterogeneous beliefs and that much of their individual forecast error is idiosyncratic, allowing aggregation to reduce noise. A within-quarter randomization exercise quantifies this wisdom-of-crowd effect directly: the consensus forecast error declines with crowd size with an elasticity of −0.17, evidence of genuine aggregation gains. Dispersed firm-level information can thus complement professional macroeconomic forecasts, though consensus accuracy is ultimately bounded by shared errors rather than crowd size.
JEL Classification: C53; D84; E37;
https://doi.org/10.29338/wp2026-17
Access Documents
Bibliographic Information
Provider: Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta
Part of Series: FRB Atlanta Working Paper
Publication Date: 2026-10-15
Number: 2026-17